Maddux of 2012. Hat tip to Joe Blanton! Over the last ten years, this is only the 11th Maddux on fewer than 90 pitches (sort of a SuperMaddux, you might say). Hours later, in Anaheim, during the last game of the night, the Blue Jays' Brandon Morrow was sitting at just 85 pitches as he headed out for the 9th inning. He had an excellent chance at throwing the second Maddux of the day! Alas, an 8-pitch battle against Erick Aybar all but ended that chance, and when Mike Trout watched strike one go by with two outs, the dream was over. Morrow wound up using 102 pitches to finish off his shutout. Close, but no cigar.
Two Madduxes in one day would truly have been special. It hasn't happened since 2005, and has occurred just six times altogether in the 25 years I have access to pitch count data for:
May 31, 1988: Dave Stieb (Blue Jays over Brewers) and Andy Hawkins (Padres over Phillies)
Stieb was one of the best pitchers of the 1980s and deserves more renown. This was a one-hit beauty for him. Hawkins is probably best known for pitching a no hitter in a game his team lost.
August 2, 1989: John Cerutti (Blue Jays over Royals) and Ken Howell (Phillies over Cubs)
This was one of just two shutouts Cerutti threw in his career. Ken Howell led the National League in wild pitches in 1989, making him something of an unlikely candidate to throw a Maddux.
June 30, 1992: Bill Krueger (Twins over Angels) and Scott Sanderson (Yankees over Royals)
Krueger gave up only 2 hits in his game, while Sanderson needed just 86 pitches to complete his. Neither of these guys is really a household name, but that need not be held against them.
August 16, 1992: Greg Maddux (Cubs over Astros) and Jaime Navarro (Brewers over Red Sox)
The man himself! This was Greg's final Maddux as a Cub. It was Navarro's second Maddux of 1992, further proof that not every pitcher who's thrown a Maddux was particularly Maddux like.
August 11, 1994: Greg Maddux (Braves over Rockies) and Zane Smith (Pirates over Expos)
There he is again. I told you, there could clearly be no other name for this statistic. This was the final start for each of these guys before the season-ending strike, which began the next day. Sad for both of them (sad for all of us), but especially for Maddux, who was in the midst of one of the greatest seasons in modern baseball history (seriously, click on the link and look at Maddux's 1994 numbers. Hell, look at all of his numbers).
June 14, 2005: Chris Carpenter (Cardinals over Blue Jays), Sergio Mitre (Cubs over Marlins), and Tomo Ohka (Brewers over Devil Rays)
That's right, the last time there were two Madduxes on the same day, there were actually three. Triple-Maddux! Carpenter is of course a great pitcher, he would go on to win the N.L. Cy Young award that year. On the other hand, this was the only shutout of Mitre's career, and quite possibly his best performance in the big leagues. Ohka managed to give up 9 hits in his game, tied for the second most in Maddux history.
So, there you go, only six times in the last 25 years have multiple Madduxes been thrown on the same day. Today was about as close as you can get without it actually happening. As it is, Joe Blanton joins Philip Humber on the list of pitchers who've thrown a Maddux in 2012. Clayton Kershaw and Justin Verlander they ain't, but the Maddux doesn't care about that. The Maddux is no elitist, it's there to be had by the legend and journeyman alike.